View Full Version : Salt?


izib
10-10-2006, 9:08 AM
What brand of salt do most peoplehere use? Ive been using Kent salt with no issues but its time to buy some more so im up for suggestions.

Also, where is a good place to buy salt around here (in on the west side of town). I can get 150gal online for 47.99 after shipping.

kappaknight
10-10-2006, 9:32 AM
I use Reef Crystals and I think you can buy them from Dr. Fosters shipped for around $37.

mikem.
10-10-2006, 9:37 AM
by the time you pay shipping you may as well get it from a lfs

kappaknight
10-10-2006, 11:09 AM
Not really... I found that buying multiple buckets from Dr. Fosters is cheaper than shopping at the LFS, and it's for better salt too. They don't charge extra shipping for the extra weight and it comes directly to your door.

Stanfill Reef
10-10-2006, 11:41 AM
I use Tropic Marin, more expensive but never had a problem. I get mine from bigalsonline.com.

And it is cheaper to order online and pay the freight than to get locally. I save $10-20 per bucket even paying higher shipping fees for the weight compared to the LFS.

glxtrix
10-10-2006, 12:49 PM
I'm an Instant Ocean (IO) man myself. Used it since the begining of my saltwater ventures and have never had any issues with it.

Atlanta Aquarium
10-10-2006, 1:06 PM
I always buy my salt thru dr. froster and smith. They are so much cheaper than LFS. I usually buy anywhere between 5 to 10 buckets (5 gallons) along with other things. The freight is very mininal. I think it came out between 2 to 5% of the total invoice. What I paid extra on freight, I more than save on the different in taxes since there is not tax buying on the net so far.

There is no weight charge. I think they done away with that. Even before they done away with the weight charge, I always wait until they have special. They ran special all the time. Plus a lot of other things are much cheaper buying online also. Of course, we need to support our LFS.

burdundi
10-10-2006, 1:15 PM
I like Kent Salt. I know they had a problem with some alk earlier this year, but I believe they have resolved all problems. I have heard some good things about Tropic Marin, but I have never tried it.

I buy mine from my LFS. It does cost a little more than online, but I believe in supporting the LFS when possible and logical ($100 in LFS vs $50 online after shipping is not logical). My LFS helped me out when I had a tank leak, and met me at the store after hours so I could get some RO water when I desperately needed some in another emergency.

My two cents...

Andy

kappaknight
10-10-2006, 1:38 PM
Interesting... I don't mean to sidetrack this convo but do you shop online for other stuff?

Competition is competition...

Atlanta Aquarium
10-10-2006, 3:11 PM
Yes, I bought ton of stuff online ie. pumps, lighting, filters, additives, fish, corals. I don't think I can find things that are cheaper at LFS than online. Even lots of corals and fish, I got online also. I can't see justify paying $49.99 for a copperband fish at LFS where I can get the same fish for $28.99 online. Freight is never in issue for me since what I paid in freight will be more than made up in the saving in taxes and the cheaper price I'll be paying. Plus place like Liveaquaria will run promotion every so often where they ship for free as long as your purchase is $225.00 or more. This is nothing when fish and corals are included.

Broreefr
10-10-2006, 3:17 PM
Not really... I found that buying multiple buckets from Dr. Fosters is cheaper than shopping at the LFS, and it's for better salt too. They don't charge extra shipping for the extra weight and it comes directly to your door.

Reef Crystals
Thats the exact route I go, and because of the size and bulkiness of the buckets, the fedex man usually drops mine off early to get it out of his way. I have found some good (and bad :sad:) vendors online - but foster & Smith are far and away the best I have dealt with.

kappaknight
10-10-2006, 4:54 PM
sorry, my question is for burdundi... thanks though :)

burdundi
10-10-2006, 5:25 PM
Hey Kappa,

I don't want to hijack this thread, but I do shop online for non-reef related items. As stated above, I will buy items online when the cost is significantly more at the LFS. That's just common sense, but if its a matter of a mere 10-20%, I'll support the people that will give great advice and help me in a bind.

Again, I like Kent Salt. :) I'd like to try Tropic Marin though.

Andy

KuLLaS
10-10-2006, 11:16 PM
I use IO instant ocean and have never had any problems with it

Broreefr
10-11-2006, 7:17 AM
sorry, my question is for burdundi... thanks though :)

Water is wet
Grass is Green
The sky is Blue

Public Forums are...........public
PM's (private messages) are private

Schwaggs
10-11-2006, 9:51 PM
I get petsmart to match their online price at the store and get buckets of IO for $32 or so.

I agree, Dr. Foster & Smith is a first class operation!

WOLFIE
10-12-2006, 11:12 PM
THAT IT!!!!!!!!!!!! I am going to buy ALL my dry good from online store.

I only buy salt like 1 a year. So last month I went to a grand opening lfs and thought I support our LFS and buy BTA and salt from them.

$79.99 + tax for a bucket of reefsalt is what they charge me. I just look at Dr.Froster and Smith and saw the same bucket of salt for $37.99

I can understand LFS price is t a little more then the online price, but double the online price? :(


This is the first and the last time I am going to drive an hour to their store.

ares
10-12-2006, 11:26 PM
as I remember; the monthly group buys have salt ever 3 or 6 months I thought, and the last pricing I saw was really good; like 40$ for a bucket. about the same as online, but just pick it up in person; no shipping concerns. and you can support the LFS at the same time. unfortunatly I couldnt use it as I ordere 2 buckets of (faulty) kent salt the week before it was announced.

but I intend to use it if it happens again.

Darren24
10-13-2006, 10:38 AM
I do the same as Kappa. Reef Crystals from Drsfostersmith.com.